| Chronology | Current Month | Current Thread | Current Date |
| [Year List] [Month List (current year)] | [Date Index] [Thread Index] | [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] | [Date Prev] [Date Next] |
See if this revised version is any better:
There are innumerably many gray areas between these
extremes. We might call these mesoscopic viewpoints.
Among these is the view that divorces mechanics from
thermodynamics, as exemplified by a spinning flywheel:
in mechanics class, if somebody asks you to calculate
``the" KE of the flywheel you probably aren't expected
to include the KE of the ultramicroscopic thermal
agitation, just the rotational KE. For a flywheel,
-- The holoscopic KE is zero, because the center
of mass isn't moving;
-- The mesoscopic KE is the usual rotational KE;
and
-- The ultramicroscopic KE includes the above
plus the thermal agitation. In this viewpoint, the
thermal KE is the largest contribution unless the
flywheel is rotating pretty fast.
If somebody asks you to calculate the thermal KE, you
aren't expected to include the organized rotational KE.
So you would have to evaluate KE[microscopic] and
subtract off KE[mesoscopic].