Chronology Current Month Current Thread Current Date
[Year List] [Month List (current year)] [Date Index] [Thread Index] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Prev] [Date Next]

[Phys-l] NAEP results in 12th grade for students who took PHYSICS




Students who take PHYSICS do best on NAEP.
Tell counselors, parents, policy makers.

http://nces.ed.gov/nationsreportcard/

I quote:
"Twelfth-grade students assessed in NAEP science in 2009 were asked what science courses they had completed or were taking currently. Their responses were then collapsed into three categories to create the 2009 science coursetaking results presented below.
Twelfth-graders who took biology, chemistry, and physics scored higher on average than students who took just biology and chemistry, and both groups scored higher than those who took just biology or other science courses. ...
166 biology/chemistry/physics
148 biology/chemistry
133 Biology only or other
The proportion of students in each of the three coursetaking categories varied by student group. A higher percentage (58 percent) of Asian/Pacific Islander students than students in other racial/ethnic groups reported taking biology, chemistry, and physics, and the percentage of White students taking all three was higher (35%) than the percentages of Black (26%) and Hispanic (30%) students taking the same courses. There were no significant differences in the percentages of White, Black, and Hispanic students taking just biology and chemistry. The percentage of male students (37%) who reported taking biology, chemistry, and physics was higher than the percentage of female students (32%) taking the same courses; ...

MORE QUOTES FROM THE NAEP REPORT: GRADE 12
For this first assessment based on the new science framework, the overall average student performance at grade 12 is represented by a score of 150 on the 0 to 300 scale. Performance at or above Proficient represents a score of 179 or higher on the NAEP science assessment. About one-fifth (21 percent) of twelfth-graders performed at or above the Proficient achievement level. Average scores did not vary significantly between White and Asian/Pacific Islander students, or among students attending schools in suburban, town, and rural locations. ... One percent of students performed at the Advanced level.

Proficient (179). Students performing at the Proficient level should be able to demonstrate relationships and compare alternative models, predictions, and explanations. They should be able to explain trends among elements in the periodic table; conservation laws; chemical mechanisms for metabolism, growth, and reproduction; changes in populations due to natural selection; the evolution of the Universe; and evidence for boundaries and movements of tectonic plates. They should be able to design and critique observational and experimental studies, controlling multiple variables, using scientific models to explain results, and choosing among alternative conclusions based on arguments from evidence. They should be able to compare scientific costs or risks and benefits of alternative solutions to problems at local or regional scales.

Advanced (222). Students performing at the Advanced level should be able to use alternative models to generate predictions and explanations. They should be able to explain differences among physical, chemical, and nuclear changes; the wave and particle nature of light; paths of specific elements through living systems; responses of ecosystems to disturbances; evidence for the theory of an expanding Universe; and evidence for human effects on the Earth's biogeochemical cycles. They should be able to design and critique investigations that relate data to alternative models of phenomena. They should be able to compare costs or risks and benefits of alternative solutions to problems at local, regional, and global scales.

Because NAEP assessments cover a breadth of content in each subject area and include more questions than any one student could reasonably answer, each student takes just a portion of the assessment. The 179 questions included in the twelfth-grade science assessment were divided into 11 sections, each containing between 16 and 18 questions depending on the balance between multiple-choice and constructed-response questions. Each student responded to two 25-minute sections.
37.5% physical science, 37.5% life science, 25% earth and space sciences