Chronology Current Month Current Thread Current Date
[Year List] [Month List (current year)] [Date Index] [Thread Index] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Prev] [Date Next]

Re: Challenging the laws of physics



The idea of catalytic fusion was summarized for us by
Leight (see below). In the spirit of promoting student's
excitement let me speculate and ask some questions.

1) Is it fair to assume that liquid D2 can be produced
in a cryogenic lab?
2) If a muon stopped in this liquid can cuase fusion
of many pairs of D2, such as 10 or 100, then we
should be able to create a cold fusion reactor by
producing a sufficiently strong muonic beam. As
I recall a "muon factory" existed at Nevis lab of
Columbia University (1970's ?) in New Jersey.
Does it still exist?
3) I have no idea what cross sections for absorbing
muons (creating muonic atoms) are at different
speeds. Knowing them would help to explore
this idea quantitatively. Any suggestions? Try
to show that this kind of reactor is practically
impossible or that it would produce less energy
that is needed to keep it going.

Leigh Palmer wrote:

and Ludwik Kowalski asked:

Can you remind us essential physics of "catalyzed fusion"
Leigh? Make it as simple as possible. Unfortunately, most
people remember only pseudoscience aspects of the claims
and not the ideas on which they were based. These ideas
were taken seriously by many, at least for a short time.

Turn a negative muon loose in a bucket of deuterium and it will quickly
bind to a deuteron, displacing that deuteron's orbital electron. This
happens because the muon is more massive than the electron and so has a
smaller ground state orbital. This much smaller "muonic atom" now gets
much closer to another, normal, deuterium nucleus than would another
normal deuterium atom. The consequent electrostatic potential
barrier between deuterons is greatly reduced, and fusion can occur with
higher probability at lower temperatures than those usually required
for deuteron-deuteron fusion. (At the temperatures required for this
ordinary, uncatalyzed fusion the deuterons do not even have electrons
to help them get close - they are completely ionized.) Once a fusion
has occurred the negative muon wanders promiscuously about in the
deuterium until it finds another happily bonded deuterium atom to
disrupt, and seduces the deuteron to its destruction. Thus one muon can
participate in the fusion of more than one pair of deuterons. That is
a catalytic process. The catalytic agent survives the fusion reaction
and lives to participate in successive reactions.

The limitation on this catalysis is, of course, the finite life of the
muon, about two microseconds. While long by nuclear standards, this
lifetime is too short to make the process economical. The best that can
be expected (this from fallible memory) is of the order of 100 fusions
per muon. Of course there are variables to tune (e.g. density) and
other, related reactions to consider (e.g. muon catalyzed deuterium-
tritium fusion), but so far no one has made an IPO on this phenomenon,
or at least not one that I would buy.

Leigh