Chronology Current Month Current Thread Current Date
[Year List] [Month List (current year)] [Date Index] [Thread Index] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Prev] [Date Next]

Re: Our 'humiliating' mistakes.





An error of the same sort as mine was made once by Farrington Daniels,
a Chemistry Professor at the University of Wisconsin. Just before a
freshman lecture Daniels did a calculation which indicated to him that
the metabolic heat required to melt thirty grams of ice would offset
3000 Calories of dietary intake. He made the mistake of blurting out
his discovery to the class, at which point a student respectfully
inquired about the possibility that Daniels had confused calories and
Calories. Of course he had; the requirement was to eat thirty
...
Leigh


Hi all,
I remember once the list advertised me ther was a difference
between 'calories' and 'Calories'...
Is this really a standard? In the I.S. of units, we are told
to use :
kC, MC, mC, muC, pC,...

I guess it is only a U.S. distinction, I've never before seen it.

Indeed, is it really usefui? convenient?
I can hardly accept that such tiny differences can be given
any meaning without introducing a source of ambiguity,
misunderstandings.

Physics tries to provide a language fre from ambiguities, isn't
that tiny distinction between 'c' an 'C' put too far?

What sense does it has to discuss if 's' is more
adequate than 'seg' or not if one accepts such former
distinction?

I hope that nice atmosphere againts mistakes,errors and
silly questions is still alive...

Regards,
M.A.Santos
msantos@etse.urv.es