Chronology Current Month Current Thread Current Date
[Year List] [Month List (current year)] [Date Index] [Thread Index] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Prev] [Date Next]

[Phys-L] Re: Florida gets an F in science



I note with some interest that the chief author is Paul Gross who is
on one of the poles in the science wars. See for example:
Higher Superstition by Gross and Levitt, or
Flight from Science and Reason ed Gross, Levitt, Lewis.

Surely this taints the document as politically motivated rather than
a balanced analysis.

do enjoy the new year all.

joe

Joseph J. Bellina, Jr. Ph.D.
Professor of Physics
Saint Mary's College
Notre Dame, IN 46556

On Dec 30, 2005, at 12:38 PM, Robert B Zannelli wrote:

Gov. Jeb Bush staked out a curious position on a hot-button issue
last week:
Florida's K-12 science standards need beefing up, he said. But
Darwin's
theory of evolution should not be part of them.
Had they heard, many scientists probably would have cringed.
Darwin's theory is a pillar of modern biology. And a new state-by-
state
analysis by an influential education foundation concludes that
Florida's
standards are among the worst in the nation - with a big reason
being its failure to
adequately explain evolution.
The report by the Washington,D.C.-based Fordham Institute calls
Florida's
standards "thin," "naive," "disappointing" - and in some cases,
flat wrong.
"The superficiality of the treatment of evolutionary biology alone
justifies
the grade "F,' " it says. "But there is in any case scant mitigation
elsewhere in these documents."
Critics say the report exposes a glaring oversight in Bush's education
revamp, which has focused mostly on reading and math in early
grades. It also adds
urgency to a pending review of Florida's science standards, which some
observers say could devolve into a culture war showdown over
evolution and
intelligent design.
Bush's off-the-cuff remarks came in response to reporters'
questions after a
hurricane-related meeting in South Florida.
Evolution "is a scientific theory and he's not opposed to it being
taught in
classrooms," Bush spokesman Russell Schweiss later clarified. "But
he doesn't
think it should be necessarily dictated in the standards."
"Oh, boy," University of South Florida chemistry professor Gerry
Meisels said
Thursday, when told of Bush's position. Meisels directs the state's
Coalition for Science Literacy. "Frankly, the state of Florida
will be embarrassed,
nationally and internationally, if it takes that position."
Science is a hot topic nationwide: The federal No Child Left Behind
Act
mandates that all states begin annual standardized testing in
science by the
2007-08 school year, and a barrage of recent studies show American
students
falling behind their global peers in math and science.
Industry groups are sounding alarms over the fallout in economic
competition,
but science educators say average citizens need to be scientifically
literate, too, to get a handle on everything from global warming
and pollution to
hurricanes and bird flu.
"It is important to have more scientists and engineers," said Matt
Werhner,
program manager for physical sciences at Hillsborough Community
College. "But
we're going to have many more citizens voting on what the
scientists and
engineers are doing."
The Fordham analysis concludes standards nationwide have not
improved since
the institute's last review in 2000. The same number of states
earned A or B
grades, while slightly more failed.
Among the shortcomings: Trying to teach too much; taking a hands-on
approach
to "absurd" levels; and watering down evolution "in response to
religious and
political pressures."
"A number of states have resisted this madness in their science
standards but
too many are fudging or obfuscating the entire basis on which biology
rests," says the report, which was chiefly authored by biologist
Paul Gross, former
head of the Marine Biological Laboratory at Woods Hole, Mass., and
a former
provost at the University of Virginia.
Florida was among 15 states that earned F grades, along with
Alabama and
Mississippi in the South.
Georgia got a B.
South Carolina got an A.
The institute took Florida to task for a "prevalence of errors in
fact and
presentation" in some subject areas. Example: Florida's standards
say a
second-grader should know "a thermometer measures the amount of
heat absorbed by an
object."
"This is careless and false: a thermometer measures temperature, or
better,
changes in temperature, not the amount of heat absorbed," the
report says. "We
hope that any second-grade teacher who cannot distinguish between
heat and
temperature will not pass this disability on to the students."
Florida's standards were slated for review next year. But the
Department of
Education decided to hold off until 2007 or 2008, citing a
longer-than-expected review of math and language arts standards
and bad timing with an ongoing
textbook review.
Critics suggest political considerations: Elections for governor
and the
state Legislature are next year, and the teaching of evolution and/or
intelligent design could become a potent issue.
Florida's standards were last revised in 1996. They don't mention
evolution
by name but reference some of its core principles, including the
fact that
species change over time.
Fordham reviewers were not impressed: "Loose, if not incorrect,
generalities
offered as standards," they concluded.
In his brief remarks, Bush, a Catholic who believes God created
humans, did
not offer a detailed explanation for his position or what changes
he would
like to see. It's also unclear how much influence he may wield.
The Department
of Education's standards review process is lengthy and includes
input from
science teachers and the public. The ultimate decision rests with
the state
Board of Education.
Bush leaves office in January 2007, but the board is likely to
still have a
majority of his appointees when it's time to vote.
Pinellas County science supervisor Bob Orlopp said earlier this
month that
postponing the standards review isn't a problem. But many science
supervisors
want to see changes, he said, and many agree with the institute's
conclusion
that Florida's standards try "to cover everything."
Many students don't retain much science knowledge unless teachers
drill deep
on core issues, he said.
"The standards we have are good," he said. "I just think there's
too much."
Evolution aside, Florida has other hurdles to clear to improve science
literacy, including a critical shortage in its number of highly
qualified science
teachers. The state will need 4,500 next year alone, yet all of
Florida's
universities combined are expected to produce about 200. Many
districts will be
forced to turn to teachers trained in other fields.
Another problem: Students' basic skills in reading comprehension
and math.
In Hillsborough Community College science classes, many recent high
school
graduates have "dismal" reading skills, said Mara Manis, HCC's
program manager
for biological sciences. So dismal, she said, that before a recent
science
test, she had to explain the difference between "preceding" and
"proceeding."
HCC science instructors also say student math skills are so weak
they can't
apply the science they do learn. Manis said many students don't
know 1 in 4 is
25 percent.
Florida's K-12 teachers "teach all the right things," she said. But
too many
students "just fill their heads with other cr--."
_______________________________________________
Phys-L mailing list
Phys-L@electron.physics.buffalo.edu
https://www.physics.buffalo.edu/mailman/listinfo/phys-l