Chronology Current Month Current Thread Current Date
[Year List] [Month List (current year)] [Date Index] [Thread Index] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Prev] [Date Next]

Re: navigation riddle

Quoting "RAUBER, JOEL" <Joel.Rauber@SDSTATE.EDU>:

| It is amusing to muse about what gives this puzzle its
| zest.
| We note that the solution-set is non-compact. That is,
| the southern solutions are spectacularly different from
| the northern solution.
| It seems that as a general rule, knowing one solution
| forms some sort of psychological impediment to finding
| other solutions. The mind is attracted to the first
| solution like a moth to candle.

If you are old enough, the question is more or less identical to a
widely spread set of riddles that were spread around in the seventies.
And the description of the problem was followed by the question: What
color are the bears?

This adds further impediment to thinking of the southern hemisphere
solution set.

Joel R

Is the impediment that there are no polar bears in Antarctica?:) Whatever, I
was interested in what John said about how we know when we have the whole
solution set when a problem may not easily reduce to a mathematically solvable
form. Like he said when setting the riddle, you have to think outside the
square, then maybe think outside the square beyond that.