Chronology | Current Month | Current Thread | Current Date |
[Year List] [Month List (current year)] | [Date Index] [Thread Index] | [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] | [Date Prev] [Date Next] |
Greetings,
Ok, I am stumped by the Physlet on fluids found at (among other places):
<http://webphysics.davidson.edu/physletprob/ch8_problems/ch8_11_fluids/fluids_2.html>
The alleged answer is that "B" is the only "physical" animation,
but I do not see why the block of wood will float higher in this
animation as oil is drawn away but before the block of wood
breaks the surface of the oil.
By Archimedes Principle and the equilibrium principle, the
weight of the block (constant) should equal the weight of
the fluids displaced;
which would be the sum of the (oil displaced)'s weight and
the (water displaced)'s weight. Why would the ratio of these
two weights change when the block is less deep under the oil?
If we calculate the buoyancy force based on the difference
between the water's pressure pushing up on the bottom
surface of the block and the oil's pressure pushing down
on the top surface, again I do not see why this "difference"
would be different before the oil no longer covers the top
surface of the block.
Animation "A" does not seem physical to me because once
the block is no longer under the oil, it should sink deeper
into the water.
I would appreciate someone else's insight into this.
Thanks,
Stuart Leinoff
Professor of Physics
Science Division Chair
ACC