Chronology | Current Month | Current Thread | Current Date |
[Year List] [Month List (current year)] | [Date Index] [Thread Index] | [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] | [Date Prev] [Date Next] |
Situation 1. Suppose I hold two equally positively-charged particles, q1 and
q2, a distance r12 apart. If I keep hold of q1 and release q2, q2 flies off
to a place infinitely far away and gains kinetic energy equal to E2. I then
release q1, which stays put since q2 is now infinitely far away. The total
energy of the system is E2.
Situation 2. Suppose I hold two equally positively-charged particles, q1 and
q2, a distance r12 apart. If I release both particles at the same time,
they fly away from each other. When they are infinitely far away from each
other, each has an energy E12. The total energy of the system is 2*E12.
In situation 1, I did no work on either q1 or q2. I admit that my muscles
converted chemical energy to heat energy in the process of holding onto q1,
but I still did no work *on q1*. q1's electric field did work on q2. The
work done by the q1's electric field on q2 equals the kinetic energy gained
by q2, E2.
In situation 2, I did no work on either q1 or q2. Is E1 equal to 2*E12?