Re: "4/3 Problem" Resolution (fwd), comment on

[David Rutherford <drutherford@SOFTCOM.NET>]

On Mon, 14 May 2001 21:38:42 -0500, Jack Uretsky <jlu@HEP.ANL.GOV> wrote:

> Dear David-
>        The point is that I did NOT have your permission to post our
> private conversation on the web,

I gave you my permission to post our private conversations. I have nothing
to hide. If you have nothing to hide, then please give me your permission to
post our conversations.

> nor do you have mine.  I have stated
> my position to the group. If you wish to explain your position, you
> are free to do so.

It would be much more informative if I could, at least, post the questions
you asked and my answers to those questions, since others probably have
similar questions regarding the gauge invariance of my equations. I think I
explained very clearly to you why my equations _are_ gauge invariant, but
you chose to ignore my explanations. Would you agree to let me post your
questions and my answers to those questions?

[ ] yes

[ ] no

>        It is clear to me that we have two totally disparate opinions
> about almost everything.  Since we seem to have almost no means of
> communication with each other, we have no alternative but to communicate
> through the group.  That, by the way, is what peer review  is all about.

Peer review is review by _all_ of the peers, not just you. That's the
beauty of the internet. Let's make it public and see what other _peers_
have to say about it.

Regards,
Dave