Chronology Current Month Current Thread Current Date
[Year List] [Month List (current year)] [Date Index] [Thread Index] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Prev] [Date Next]

RE: "quantization"




------ =_NextPart_000_01BD8121.C15AD020
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit



-----Original Message-----
From: JACK L. URETSKY (C) 1996; HEP DIV., ARGONNE NATIONAL LAB, ARGONNE, IL 60439 [SMTP:JLU@hep.anl.gov]
Sent: Thursday, May 14, 1998 3:57 AM
To: phys-l@atlantis.uwf.edu
Cc: JLU@hep.anl.gov
Subject: Re: "quantization"


Hi all-
On non-unique theories. Question is, what do you mean by
"mathematically equivalent". Take electrodynamics in two different gauges.
Are the two formulations "mathematically equivalent"? We know that they
ar e physically equivalent because they make identical predictions about
physics.
Another case in point, is Hamiltonian mechanics "mathematically
equivalent" to Newtonian mechanics? What is your criterion?
Regards,
Jack


------ =_NextPart_000_01BD8121.C15AD020
Content-Type: application/ms-tnef
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
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------ =_NextPart_000_01BD8121.C15AD020--