Chronology Current Month Current Thread Current Date
[Year List] [Month List (current year)] [Date Index] [Thread Index] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Prev] [Date Next]

Re: [Phys-L] Thermal Physics solution manual



I found this

Are that solutions good?

http://waxworksmath.com/Authors/N_Z/Schroeder/schroeder.html

2015-12-08 7:32 GMT-03:00 Diego Saravia <dsa@unsa.edu.ar>:

If a student wants to solve an exercise by itself it always can do it.

If a student want to know if he obtained a good solution he will need an
oficial answer. If there are non oficial ones available it always exists a
risk that they are non correct or not enough clear ones.

I think is better to have a free (as freedom) available solution manual.
So solution 2 is the good one for me. Is the only one that assure that
"always" that material will continue existing.

The risk of non-good teachers teaching bad solutions is a worst situation
than one in wich there is available a good solutions manual for teachers
and students.




2015-12-07 21:34 GMT-03:00 Daniel V. Schroeder <dschroeder@weber.edu>:

Dear colleagues,

The Instructors' Solution Manual for my textbook, An Introduction to
Thermal Physics, is now out of print. The publisher, Pearson, is not
interested in reprinting it, but they have offered to post it online as a
pdf that instructors could download after logging on with a password.
However, there are other options. As I see it, the choices are as follows:

1. Post the pdf on the Pearson web site, protected by a password so only
instructors can download it.

2. Release the manual from copyright and let anyone distribute it
freely. I would then post it on my own web site, and it would become a
students' solution manual.

3. Stop distributing the manual but keep it under copyright, so it would
become less available and the only legal copies would be those that have
already been distributed.

4. Some combination of the above. For example, a subset of solutions
could be released from copyright for distribution to students, while others
could be provided only to instructors or not at all.

I'm writing to solicit your input on this decision. Personally, I am
torn. Part of me wishes I had never written a solution manual, because its
mere existence conveys the message that solutions are things that are
handed down by authority (the textbook author) rather than things you
should figure out for yourself and think about critically. On the other
hand, many instructors seem to depend on the solution manual, especially
when they are pressed for time.

Of course I am aware of the fact that scanned copies of the solution
manual are already being distributed among students, illegally, on the
internet. My impression is that Pearson's legal department can make
illegal downloading less convenient, but cannot stop it entirely. If we
release a high-quality pdf of the manual, then its distribution in
electronic form will become somewhat more convenient.

What should we do?

Dan Schroeder
Weber State University


_______________________________________________
Forum for Physics Educators
Phys-l@www.phys-l.org
http://www.phys-l.org/mailman/listinfo/phys-l




--
Diego Saravia
Diego.Saravia@gmail.com
NO FUNCIONA->dsa@unsa.edu.ar

====================================================================
"Disclaimer:" Haré lo que desee con los correos que reciba, quien no este
de acuerdo, que se abstenga de enviarme correo a mí o a las listas donde
este suscripto.
En particular NO VALE ningun "disclaimer" que indique que el correo
enviado es privado o sujeto a normas de empresas, gobiernos, u
organizaciones de cualquier tipo.
Con relación a los estados y sus leyes, analizare cualquier norma
aplicable en el territorio donde eventualmente actúe en el momento, escucho
a cualquiera que tenga algo que decir.
Con respecto en particular a los derechos de autor, salvo acuerdo previo,
gozaré plenamente de las 4 libertades con todo lo que reciba,
considerandolo, en cuanto a lo patrimonial,
como propio.
====================================================================




--
Diego Saravia
Diego.Saravia@gmail.com
NO FUNCIONA->dsa@unsa.edu.ar

====================================================================
"Disclaimer:" Haré lo que desee con los correos que reciba, quien no este
de acuerdo, que se abstenga de enviarme correo a mí o a las listas donde
este suscripto.
En particular NO VALE ningun "disclaimer" que indique que el correo enviado
es privado o sujeto a normas de empresas, gobiernos, u organizaciones de
cualquier tipo.
Con relación a los estados y sus leyes, analizare cualquier norma aplicable
en el territorio donde eventualmente actúe en el momento, escucho a
cualquiera que tenga algo que decir.
Con respecto en particular a los derechos de autor, salvo acuerdo previo,
gozaré plenamente de las 4 libertades con todo lo que reciba,
considerandolo, en cuanto a lo patrimonial,
como propio.
====================================================================