Chronology Current Month Current Thread Current Date
[Year List] [Month List (current year)] [Date Index] [Thread Index] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Prev] [Date Next]

Re: [Phys-l] Lecture vs Advocacy



This experience is precisely an illustration of the problem. Anyone who
already has an understanding of science and is interested in it would have
their attention captured by the name Faraday. But those who have no
interest will pass over it.

Lectures have some value when the audience is interested and attuned to what
is being said, but in general this is not the case. Lectures also do not in
general change paradigms, or misconceptions. Interactive lectures do a
better job as long as the audience goes along with it. Essentially the
misconception needs to be brought out, and then refuted by strong evidence.

There is some evidence that a video of a give and take conversation where a
misconception is refuted works better than a straight lecture. But the
conventional straight lecture does not work well at all. Only the deserving
who are interested in and already know something about the topic might gain
from it. The uniformed who need education the most will usually gain
little.

John M. Clement
Houston, TX



I was driving a trailer to a horse show yesterday. NPR was tuned;
Click And Clack had finished and a comedian's talk show was running.
Feldman is not a particular enthusiasm of mine.
But he does invite an eclectic variety of guests to interview.

I was not paying much attention. The guest mentioned Faraday.
I have his experimental researches. Then my attention was quickly
riveted.
The guest - Johnson - mentioned a gas lantern with a polarizer placed
before a big electromagnet.

Faraday looked through another polarizer - as it might be, a pair
of sunglasses,
as Johnson put it, to extinguish the lantern's light. When he
switched on the
electromagnet, the lantern reappeared. I knew about that. You knew about
that
effect too - the rotation of the polarization plane of light by a magnet.

Johnson was talking about his book - Ten Beautiful Experiments - and I was
shocked how powerfully this commentary differed from my received opinion
about the inadequacy of the lecture method.
As far as I can tell, lectures do not generally convey enthusiasm,
insight
and pleasure: but advocates overcome our barriers with just these
virtues.