Chronology Current Month Current Thread Current Date
[Year List] [Month List (current year)] [Date Index] [Thread Index] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Prev] [Date Next]

Re: corrupting the youth



Or if its a piece of opaque cardboard, you
can paint a dot on one side and say the normal vector must point that way.

I wrote:

Yes, assuming the cardboard also has a sense of circulation
marked on it, perhaps by considering it a bivector and
ordering the edges (first this edge, then this other edge).

Which was OK in context, but perhaps some elaboration
would be helpful:

1) If all you want to know is which side of the cardboard
is which, all you have to do is paint a dot on one side.

2) If you want to designate a direction of circulation in
the plane of the cardboard, you can either
2a) draw an arc-with-arrowhead on it, or
2b) mark one side _and_ apply some pre-existing Right-Hand
Rule or the equivalent.

Note that in case (2a) you can mark the direction of
circulation without specifying a preference for either
face. You can put matching arcs on both faces, or you
can put tiny arrowheads on the _edge_ of the cardboard
(running around the edge, belt-wise).

3) If you don't have a pre-existing Right-Hand Rule and
you want to use the cardboard to _define_ what you mean
by right-handed, you must mark a direction of circulation
_and_ paint a dot on one side. This creates a chiral
object. (Situations (1) and (2a) neither require nor
create any notion of handedness.)