Chronology Current Month Current Thread Current Date
[Year List] [Month List (current year)] [Date Index] [Thread Index] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Prev] [Date Next]

Re: help in general physics

Al Clark wrote (in part)
At the least, I want to ask for recommendations of alternative textbooks
for general physics that pay more attention to problem solving skills, or
have a more effective approach to developing those skills, while still
providing a solid foundation in physics. I would also appreciate
information or references about teaching strategies that others have found
to be effective, what topics must be covered in general physics (and to
what depth), what topics can effectively be postponed to later, etc.
Thanks in advance.

I have been using Al Van Heuvelen's ALPS Kits (Active Learning
Problem Sets) for the past year in the mechanics half of this course.
The encourage (require) students to draw pictures, draw motion and
free-body diagrams, define symbols and coordinate systems, then
finally do the math, and at the end evaluate the solution. In
general they work well, especially for weaker students. By
emphasizing qualitative solutions, they strongly reduce the tendancy
of students to solve a problem by hunting for the correct equation.

On the other hand, they do slow down the course (probably a good
thing). The allow (encourage?) some students to avoid reading the
textbook and thus not get the broader approach and
theoretical/cultural introduction. They do not use graphical
techniques at all, nor do they do any calculus. While I like the
order of momentum and angular motion before work and energy, the
order is not supported by Halliday/Resnick/Walker.

On the whole, I would strongly recommend that you look at them.
Publisher is Hayden-McNeil 313 729-5550.